Benjamin Moore Advance: Honest Review (2026)

Disclosure: Affiliate links — we earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. Picks are based on independent testing.

Verdict — ★ 4.5 / 5

Advance is the best brush-and-roll cabinet paint a homeowner can buy in 2026. Self-levels like oil. Cleans up with water. Survives a kitchen for 7–10 years if you let it cure properly. Two real cons: $80–95/gal and a 30-day cure schedule.

Buy this if: you’re painting kitchen cabinets, bathroom vanities, or interior trim and you want the closest thing to a sprayed factory finish from a brush. Skip this if: you’re patient-impaired, on a tight budget, or doing exterior work (Advance is interior — for exterior trim use Aura Exterior).

What is Benjamin Moore Advance?

Advance is Benjamin Moore’s waterborne alkyd — a “best of both worlds” formula that gives you the leveling and hardness of oil-based enamel with water cleanup and modern VOC compliance. Released in 2009, reformulated in 2018 for faster cure. Available in BM’s full color deck (3,400+ tints) at satin, semi-gloss, and high-gloss.

Spec sheet

What it’s good at

• Self-leveling. With a quality brush (Wooster Silver Tip, Purdy XL), brush marks disappear as the paint dries. Closest you get to a sprayed finish without a sprayer.
• Scrubbability. Survives kitchen wipe-down at month-2 and beyond. Marker, mustard, and Krud Kutter all wipe off without ghosting.
• Color range. Full BM tint base — 3,400+ colors, no compromises.
• Yellowing resistance. Modern waterborne alkyd retains the leveling of oil without the yellowing tendency. Whites stay white at year 5 in indirect light. (In direct UV, all whites yellow some — see “Long-term wear” below.)
• Adhesion to a properly primed substrate. Stix-then-Advance is the most reliable cabinet system we’ve tested.

What it’s not great at

• Long recoat window. 16 hours between coats. You’re committing to a multi-day project. Sherwin Emerald Urethane recoats at 4 hours, which can collapse a project to one weekend instead of three.
• Long full-cure time. 30 days before normal abuse. Kids’ hands off the doors for a month, and even at week three, fingernails will print the film.
• Price. $80–95/gal at BM stores. Not a budget pick. Cabinet Coat at $50–55/gal is the easy step-down for budget-constrained projects.
• Limited retail. BM stores carry it reliably; big-box stores don’t. If you’re on a Sunday-morning emergency, that 30-mile drive to a BM store is the friction.
• Sheen options. No flat or eggshell offerings. Advance is a satin-and-up product — appropriate for cabinets and trim, but you can’t use it for a wall paint where a softer sheen is preferred.

Long-term wear — what 12 months of cabinet use looks like

The fairest stress test for cabinet paint is 12 months in a daily-driver kitchen. Here’s what we’ve observed from our own test panels and from contractor feedback:

• Edge wear at door pulls. Most cabinet paint shows wear at year 1 around the pull, where fingernails strike the door surface. Advance shows light burnishing here at month 12 — visible only at six inches under raking light, not at conversational distance.
• Top edge of base cabinets. This is where dishes, pans, and groceries land. Advance survives the impact noticeably better than commodity latex; minor scratches fill with a touch-up brush from the same can.
• Yellowing on white in direct sun. A south-facing run of white Advance cabinets shows ΔE ~3 yellowing at 12 months — perceptible against fresh paint but not obvious in isolation. North-facing or interior runs show ΔE <1.5.
• Soft-spot recovery. Advance is fully cured at 30 days — but a deep dent at week 2 (before full cure) won’t pop back the way fresh latex does. The film hardness lock-in time is real.

For benchmark: Sherwin Emerald Urethane shows tighter scratch resistance at year 1 (its harder cured film), Cabinet Coat shows slightly more wear at the pull edges, Behr Premium Cabinet & Trim shows visibly more burnishing across the same time.

Sheen behavior — satin vs semi-gloss vs high-gloss

Advance ships in three sheens. They behave differently enough to call out:

• Satin (~28 GU at 60°): the quietest, most forgiving sheen. Hides minor brush texture and substrate imperfection best. Default for bathroom vanities and low-light kitchens. Slightly less wipe-resistant than semi-gloss but acceptable for daily use.
• Semi-gloss (~50 GU): the cabinet workhorse. The reflectivity reads as a quality kitchen finish, the surface cleans well against grease, and the slightly higher film build resists abrasion better than satin. The trade-off: every dust speck and brush imperfection shows.
• High-gloss (~85 GU): dramatic, jewelry-store reflectivity. Use only on substrates that are dead-flat (sprayed factory doors, glass-smooth MDF). Brushed high-gloss is almost always a regret — orange-peel and brush marks magnify under raking light.

For 90% of cabinet projects, semi-gloss is the right pick. For sun-drenched white cabinets where yellowing is a concern, drop to satin (less film, slower yellowing). High-gloss is a deliberate aesthetic choice, not a default.

Color rendering — what to expect from the BM tint base

Advance’s tint base is identical to BM’s other premium lines, which means the full 3,400-color deck transfers cleanly. Notes from the test panels:

• Whites and off-whites render slightly cooler than the same color in Regal Select (BM’s wall paint). This is the alkyd resin’s optical character; it’s flattering on cabinets in warm rooms.
• Deep colors (blacks, deep blues, deep greens) need Advance’s deep-base formula, which can take 3 coats over tinted gray primer to fully cover. Plan accordingly.
• Reds and oranges can drift slightly toward a warmer tone over the first 30 days as the film cures. Apply a sample, wait 30 days, evaluate before committing the full kitchen.

If you’re matching a printed color reference (RAL, Pantone) — order a custom sample mix from your BM store rather than relying on the off-the-shelf tint card.

Who it’s for / not for

Buy this if: you’re refinishing kitchen cabinets, painting a vanity, or doing interior trim where the finish quality reads at arm’s length. The price-to-result ratio earns its keep on these jobs.

Skip this if: you need fast turnaround, you’re on a tight budget (Cabinet Coat is 70% of the finish at half the price), or you need exterior performance (use Aura Exterior).

Honest alternatives

Cheaper: INSL-X Cabinet Coat ($50–55/gal)

Same parent company (BM owns INSL-X). 80% of the finish at half the price. Less perfectly self-leveling — at six inches under raking light, you can see slight texture where Advance is glass — but pro contractors swear by it for value. The self-priming claim works on previously-painted cabinets in good condition (still need Stix on glossy factory finishes). The right choice when budget is the constraint.

Pricier upgrade: Sherwin-Williams Emerald Urethane Trim Enamel ($95–110/gal)

Hardest cured film in the cabinet category — survives kitchen abuse marginally better than Advance at 12 months. Faster recoat (4h vs 16h) is the killer feature for weekend warriors who want a one-weekend project. Smaller color deck (Emerald-line tints only). Slight ammonia smell on application — ventilation matters more here. The right choice for high-traffic family kitchens or when you want the project done in two days.

Specialty: Behr Premium Cabinet, Door & Trim Enamel ($45–50/gal)

Budget pick. Half the price of Advance, available at every Home Depot. Visible brush marks if you don’t spray. Soft cure for 60–90 days — meaningfully longer than the others. Yellowing risk on whites in direct sun is higher. The right choice for rentals, low-traffic kitchens, or beach houses where you can leave the cabinets alone for the first two months.

Why we still pick Advance as the default

None of the alternatives match Advance’s combination of brush-self-leveling, color range, and post-cure durability at the $80–95 price point. Cabinet Coat saves money but shows texture; Emerald Urethane wins on cured hardness but at higher cost; Behr saves more money but pays for it in soft-cure patience. Advance is the middle path that wins on most criteria most of the time.

Where to buy

Related

• Best paint for kitchen cabinets →
• How to paint kitchen cabinets →
• Oil vs water-based →